Revewier 1

• Added introductory paragraph explaining the benefits of tidy evaluation with concrete examples.
• Clarified that tidy evaluation was inspired by base R fuctions.
• I did not add an explanation of .data and .env pronouns, since these are now rarely needed and while technically precise, I don’t believe they aid the high-level discussion here.
• Fixed the identified spelling and grammar errors, and added a citation for R itself.
• Shrunk the tidymodels section and folded it into Posit section.

Reviewer 2

• Clarified that reasons of performance is one reason to introduce new data structures
• Briefly mention some of the other approaches and why I didn’t say more about them (I’ve forgotten)
• Mentioned SQL including some likes and dislikes.
• Added a note about how I met Winston and JJ
• Made it more clear who the founding and past tidymodels team members are.
• Added mention of R forwards
• Noted community discussion of licensing changes